Weekly E-News
Head Start Rule Changes Move Forward: What Does the Research Say?
November 20, 2026
Hot Topics
Head Start Rule Changes Move Forward: What Does the Research Say?
On November 16, 2026, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) published a Final Rule rescinding the 2024 Head Start teacher wage regulations.
What’s Changing:
- The Rollback: The 2024 regulations required programs to establish wage scales and reach pay parity by 2031—bringing Head Start salaries in line with public pre-K teachers or 90% of kindergarten teacher pay.
- The Timeline: The new rule eliminates these mandates and takes effect on January 15, 2027.
- The Rationale vs. The Research: While HHS states the rule will give local programs greater flexibility and generate cost savings to expand access, NIEER’s policy brief, The Real Cost of Rolling Back Head Start Wage Requirements, finds the move will likely worsen teacher shortages and turnover—ultimately undermining access, quality, and school readiness goals.
More Regulatory Changes on the Horizon:
Last week, HHS also sent a broader Final Rule to the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) that would remove most Head Start quality standards. The rule is now in the final stages of federal review before publication.
NIEER has released two additional policy briefs examining what the research says about key provisions in this broader rule:
Examining the Evidence:
Additionally, NIEER researchers Steve Barnett and Morgan Healy published a review through the National Education Policy Center evaluating the Heritage Foundation report that HHS cited to justify its deregulation efforts. Their review concluded that the report's use of evidence is so limited and misleading that neither its findings on Head Start’s performance nor its policy recommendations should inform decision-making.
👉 Access all of NIEER’s research on Head Start and Early Head Start here.
Executive Function as a Mediator Linking Block Play and Early Mathematics in Preschool
In Early Education and Development, Sara A. Schmitt, Everett Mahaffy, Robert J. Duncan, Daniela Alvarez-Vargas, Yitong Jiang, Emily Wilke, Janice Fong, Tracy Zehner and David J. Purpura used data from a randomized controlled trial of two treatment conditions (unstructured, free and semi-structured block play) to assess the extent to which executive function mediates both interventions’ impact on early math outcomes. The study included 230 children ages 3-6 from low-income families (50% female). Findings demonstrate that executive function mediated the effects of one of the block play conditions (free play with blocks) on children’s improvements in numeracy, but not the other condition (semi-structured block play).
NIEER Activity
New NIEER Website on Outdoor & Nature-Based Learning
You can now access all NIEER research and resources on outdoor and nature-based learning in a new webpage. The site includes new details about the National Workgroup NIEER leads to develop and strengthen policies related to outdoor and nature-based learning in state-funded preschool programs and other publicly funded settings.
Supported by the George B. Storer Foundation, this project brings together state leaders and experts to remove policy barriers and promote outdoor access. The initiative spans three cohorts across 16 different states and jurisdictions.
Access the site here.
NIEER and Early Learning Indiana Highlight Research-Practice Partnership at APPAM
NIEER's Milagros Nores and Erin Harmeyer shared details about their Research-Practice Partnership with Early Learning Indiana at the Association for Public Policy Analysis & Management (APPAM) conference in Boston earlier this month. They were joined by Indiana partners Erin Kissling, Jacqueline Strong, and Sierra Whitman.
Together, they presented research on early learning outcomes in Indiana and discussed how those insights are shaping statewide improvements in early childhood education. Their presentation emphasized why connecting research to everyday classroom practice is vital for helping Hoosier children thrive.
As part of NIEER's ongoing partnership with Early Learning Indiana, Nores also shared information about data-driven programming and policy during an "Ask the Expert" session last year. It's available to watch on YouTube.
NIEER Leaders Headline International Early Childhood Forum in Mexico
NIEER Director Steven Barnett and Co-Director of Research Milagros Nores were featured speakers at this week’s International Early Childhood Forum hosted by the Centro de Primera Infancia in Monterrey, Mexico.
Barnett shared a Keynote Address on “Early Childhood Economics, Return on Investment, and Long-Term Impact.” During the keynote, Barnett and Guillermo Torre of TecSalud del Tecnológico de Monterrey discussed what we know today about the early years that makes them a critical time for action.
Nores presented a Master Panel, “América Latina: Lo aprendido y la distancia que nos queda por recorrer (Latin America: What we have learned and the distance that remains to be covered)” with Beatriz Cardoso of Laboratório de Educação (Labedu); Katherine Strasser of the Pontifical Catholic University of Chile; and moderator Adriana Gidi of the Early Childhood Center. Nores also presented in a Reflection Session exploring how research and science can better serve the region.
The forum gathers those spearheading early childhood development across Latin America, connecting science, public policy, and community intervention.
NIEER Researchers Share Insights at National Council on Family Relations
This week, NIEER experts presented two sessions at the National Council on Family Relations’ Annual Conference, “Families at the Nexus of Law and Policy: The Intended and Unintended Consequences of Legislating Families and Relationships”:
- “State-Funded Pre-K in Mixed Delivery Systems: Including Family Child Care Homes to Support Family Choice and Equity” by GG Weisenfeld and Erin Harmeyer; and
- “Parental Home Learning Activities With Preschool Children in Classrooms Enrolled in a Teacher Professional Development Intervention” by Erin Harmeyer.
Learn more about Weisenfeld and Harmeyer’s research and partnerships focused on including family child care in state and local pre-k systems.
International Journal of Child Care and Education Policy (IJCCEP) Weekly Feature
Policy Translation for Early Childhood Education and Care: The Growing Up in New Zealand Approach
Amy L. Bird, Polly E. Atatoa Carr, Elaine Reese, and Susan M. B. Morton described how findings from the Growing Up in New Zealand longitudinal cohort study were used to inform early childhood education and care policy. Using parent reported data for 6,242 two-year-olds, the researchers examined differences in the type, amount, and quality of nonparental care, intentions to use the government’s “20 Hours ECE” program at age 3, and how these patterns varied by socioeconomic characteristics and ethnicity. Children’s care arrangements differed by maternal ethnicity, household income, neighborhood, and family structure, and several proxy indicators of care quality were lower for children of Māori, Pacific, and Asian mothers and for children living in lower-resourced areas. Although 88 percent of mothers intended to use the “20 Hours ECE” program, Asian and Pacific mothers and families relying on relatives for childcare were less likely to do so. The findings illustrate how longitudinal cohort data can support policy development while also highlighting persistent socioeconomic and ethnic disparities in early childhood education and care.
Publish in the International Journal of Child Care and Education Policy (IJCCEP)
- It’s FREE – article processing charges for all articles published in the journal are fully sponsored.
- The journal is indexed by Emerging Sources Citation Index (ESCI) and by Scopus.
- All articles are published under the Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0 license. Authors will retain copyright.
ECE Research
Syaza Soraya Sauli, Christopher Speldewinde, and Azlina Mohd Kosnin, writing in Journal of Outdoor and Environmental Education, mapped global research trends in nature-based learning in early childhood education using a bibliometric analysis of 115 Scopus indexed publications from 2009 through 2025. The researchers examined publication growth, authorship, countries and institutions, citation patterns, disciplinary areas, and emerging keywords. Research on nature-based learning increased steadily over the period, with Turkey, Australia, and the United States emerging as leading contributors and environmental science and social sciences representing the most common disciplinary areas. Recent scholarship increasingly connects nature-based learning with sustainability, STEM, outdoor pedagogy, and children’s development. The findings indicate growing interdisciplinary and international interest in nature-based approaches and provide a useful overview of where the field has developed and where future research, practice, and policy may be headed.
In Journal of Research in Special Educational Needs, Petra Gäreskog reviewed 38 studies examining how preschool teachers, childcare workers, and special educators support for children with additional needs in preschool settings. The review found that responsibilities between preschool teachers and childcare workers are often both complementary and ambiguous, with ongoing negotiation over tasks that may affect the consistency and inclusiveness of support. Special educators were frequently relied upon for specialized expertise, while childcare workers were underrepresented in the literature. The findings suggest that clearer professional roles and greater alignment in how children’s needs are understood may help improve the coherence, equity, and inclusiveness of special support in preschool.
Zeying Miao, Shiwu Li, Xuejun Ma, and Yongguang Yao, writing in Frontiers in Public Health, systematically reviewed 13 studies involving 3,562 preschool children to examine whether physical activity focused professional development for early childhood educators improves children’s activity in early childhood education and care settings. Meta analysis found that educator professional development was associated with increases in total physical activity and moderate to vigorous physical activity and with a small reduction in sedentary behavior, while no significant effect was found for light intensity physical activity. The size of the effects varied considerably across studies, and confidence in the evidence was limited by risk of bias. The findings provide preliminary support for including physical activity focused professional development in educator preparation and ongoing professional learning. They also indicate a need for stronger research to determine which professional development approaches most consistently translate into measurable changes in children’s physical activity.
Zoe Renee Finiasz and Tamar Kushnir, writing in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, examined whether group membership can influence four- and five-year-olds’ willingness to revise false beliefs when they encounter contradictory evidence. Across three experiments, children first endorsed a claim about a novel causal system and then joined a group that shared that belief. When children were told that holding the belief was a condition of belonging to the group, they were less likely to revise it after seeing evidence that it was wrong and, in one experiment, continued to act on the incorrect belief. In contrast, children readily changed their minds when the same belief was merely shared by group members but was not required for membership. The findings suggest that by preschool age, the desire to maintain group affiliation can sometimes outweigh evidence-based belief revision, pointing to early developmental roots of the tension between social belonging and truth seeking.
Opportunities
Program Officer, Children and Families, The David & Lucile Packard Foundation
Senior Director / Director of Policy and Advocacy, Early Childhood Investment Corporation
Advisory Services Analyst, Early Childhood Programs, Mathematica
Early Math, Research Scientist II, WestEd
Senior Program Officer, K-12 Scaling Measurement, Learning and Evaluation, Gates Foundation
Founding Generation Summer Fellowship for Undergraduates, International Congress of Infant Studies
Program Officer, Early Care and Education, Low Income Investment Fund (LIIF)
Senior Research Associate, Annenberg Institute, Brown University
Assistant Director for Program Evaluation, Harlem Children’s Zone
National Sales Manager, Professional Development, ZERO TO THREE
Sr. Professional Development Specialist, ZERO TO THREE
Early Education Services Program Analyst (Early Head Start), City of San Antonio
Analyst, Research and Evaluation, Illinois Action for Children
Research and Evaluation Coordinator
Early Learning Policy Associate, Texans Care for Children
Early Childhood Policy Manager, Zero to Five Montana
Research & Evaluation Manager, First Five Sonoma County
The Authors
Allison Muhlendorf manages external affairs for NIEER, including communications, earned and owned media, government relations, partnerships, and outreach.
About NIEER
The National Institute for Early Education Research (NIEER) at the Graduate School of Education, Rutgers University, New Brunswick, NJ, conducts and disseminates independent research and analysis to inform early childhood education policy.